10 Awesome DIY Halloween Dog Treats You Can Make Yourself

It’s September and already the smell of pumpkin spice is everywhere. Spooky Halloween costumes are popping up in stores and those gigantic bags of candy for trick or treaters line the shelves. 

But Halloween doesn’t mean only the hoo-man kiddos get a fun Halloween treat, does it?

Thing is, just like with our own food, sometimes store bought treats can have all sorts of ingredients, fillers or preservatives that we don’t really want to be giving to our beloved furry friends.

Luckily, making healthier homemade Halloween dog treats is pretty easy to do. After making these Halloween dog cookies and snacks, you may even get addicted to baking yummy treats for your pooch!

Are homemade dog treats good for dogs?

Absolutely! Homemade dog treats can have lots of benefits beyond just being budget-friendly.

With DIY dog treats, you know exactly what ingredients your dog is eating.

This is especially helpful if you have a dog on a restrictive diet or if your dog has allergies to certain foods.

Another benefit to homemade dog treats is that you can make them in any size or shape.

Make smaller treats for smaller dog or to use for training. Make larger treats for your large breed dogs without breaking the bank!

You may even want to consider how to start a dog treat business if you love making dog treats and have thinking about starting your own business.

What foods are toxic for dogs?

Just be sure to do your research and double check each ingredient a recipe you want to use calls for. You know your dog best.

If you are unsure about an ingredient, ask your vet if it is safe to use or just skip it.

Definitely stay away from ingredients that are known to be toxic for dogs like:

• Caffeine
• Grapes and raisins
• Macadamia nuts
• Xylitol
• Chocolate
• Yeast dough
• Fruit pits and seeds
• Avocados
• Mushrooms
• Unripe tomatoes
• Onions and garlic
• Nutmeg

How do you make healthy dog treats from scratch?

Luckily, most of the ingredients dog treat recipes call for are things you probably already have in your kitchen.

You’ll find that many dog treat recipes include common items like flour, oatmeal, eggs, or broth.

To add flavor, protein, vitamins and fiber, other ingredients will be mixed in like pumpkin puree, artificial sweetener free peanut butter, sweet potato, apples, carrots, and cheese.

How do you make Pyramid dog treats?

Pyramid dog treats are a very popular homemade dog treat that produce the really small pyramid shaped treats that are perfect for training.

They are made using a silicone “pyramid” baking sheet. 

While these silicone baking sheets weren’t originally intended for dog treats, they’ve become a popular must-have amongst dog treat makers.

They make it super easy to make a large number of small dog treats, as some molds will produce up to 500 in just one batch.

Plus you can always use the silicone pyramid mold for what it was originally intended for too!

Which silicone molds are best for dog treats?

Once you find a favorite dog treat recipe to make, you can customize your treats by using different size and shape molds.

The best mold is going to be the one that you and your dog enjoy using the most.

For instance, if you dog loves one of the pumpkin shaped treat recipes below, you can make them with a Pyramid mold to create a useful training treat instead.

There are a bunch you can try, I will share you with you the ones I use below.

I like to purchase them from Amazon because of the easy return policy.

Sometimes the molds are larger or smaller than you expected so just look for the “free returns” notation so you can try several out to see which works best for you.

These Puppy Dog Paw and Bone Silicone Molds are made from food grade silicone, are heat resistant, non-toxic and BPA free.

Temperature safe from -40 to +446 degrees Fahrenheit makes them perfect for the oven, dishwasher, freezer, or microwave.

The molds can also be used for making chocolates, ice cubes, soaps, cakes, jelly and so much more.

Our 10 Favorite Dog Treat Recipes to Try this Halloween

Your pets want to celebrate Halloween too, so try out some of these awesome Halloween pet treats you can make for your fur baby and their friends. 

 Try these gluten free Pumpkin Spice Halloween Dog Biscuits from Vintage Kitty. 

Your doggy will gobble up these Candy Corn Halloween Themed Dog Treats from 12 Tomatoes.

These Pumpkin and Brown Rice Flour Dog Treats are the perfect Halloween cookies for dogs.

Aimee created a homemade recipe combining soothing pumpkin and brown rice flour to make a scrumptious, healthy treat for your doggie friends.

These dog Halloween cookies from Home is Where the Boat Is are made with fiber filled pumpkin, proven to benefit dogs’ digestive tracts.

Pumpkin is also full of vitamins A and C, which both help to support vision and immune health in dogs.

Dogs LOVE peanut butter and pumpkin. The Cottage Market promises that her homemade Mummy Bones peanut butter dog treats is a treat they will flip for! 

These Bone Yard Pumpkin Dog Treats from Today’s Creative Life are an easy homemade dog biscuit recipe your dog will love!

These fun homemade Halloween dog treats from Dogvills are shaped and decorated to look like vibrant spiders. They look like they are so much fun to make!

They do have sugar in the icing, so you don’t want to go crazy with giving them to your dogs. 

These Skull and Crossbones Halloween Frozen Dog Treats from Beagles and Bargains are made with blueberries.

Blueberries are known to aid in cardiovascular health, lower cholesterol and sugar levels, and may even have anti-cancer properties in dogs.

They also have kale, which is a great low calorie dog friendly veggie option that is high in beta carotene, vitamin K, and vitamin C.

These easy to make Pumpkin Halloween Dog Treats from Dalmatian DIY have only four ingredients.

Golden Daily Scoop created these cool Frozen Blueberry Skull Dog Treats you whip up in a blender and freeze for about 30 mins.

Human Halloween Recipes to Try

Don’t forget to check out our list of hilarious Halloween costumes for pets. Your fur babies want to go trick or treating too!